Piano Strings

There’s nothing remarkable about it. All one has to do is hit the right keys at the right time and the instrument plays itself
Johann Sebastian Bach

I found myself recently staring down into a baby grand piano recently, and for the first time I considered the motivation for its exterior curves.  Noting the varying lengths of the piano wires for the different notes, I naturally assumed that their arrangement dictated the piano’s shape.  A little physics, as well as piano history set me straight.

First off, I used Wikipedia to refresh my memory on how to calculate the fundamental harmonics of strings, which after a little rearranging, allows me to calculate a piano string/wire’s length:

L=\frac{1}{2f}\sqrt{\frac{T}{\mu}}

So, for a given tension, T, and linear density, \mu, the length of a wire is inversely proportional to its frequency.  That rings a bell; now if we (incorrectly) assume all of wires have the same tension and linear density, we can reconstruct the trend of the wire lengths as a function of piano keys, once we know the frequency of the keys:

Note that since the values I used for tension and linear density are arbitrary, the units of length are unimportant, just their relative magnitudes.

Now compare to the inside of a piano:

Not bad, right?  Of course, there are some important differences that should be noted.  First, the piano strings are in fact not of constant linear density or tension.  Apparently, the linear density changes throughout the piano; I read somewhere that approximately every sixth string the wire gauge changes.  The tension is obviously varied in order to get precise tuning.  And the lower notes on the left hand side are rearranged completely differently, significantly changing the shape of that end of the piano.  According to this article on piano history:

Overstringing was invented by Jean Henri Pap during the 1820’s and was first patented for use in grand pianos in the United States by Henry Steinway, Jr. in 1859. When overstringing a piano, the strings are placed in a vertically overlapping slanted arrangement, with two heights of bridges on the soundboard instead of just one. This allowed for larger strings to fit within the piano case.

So to avoid the long tapering spike at the lowest notes, it appears that as a matter of convenience, they are angled to help improve the overall footprint of the piano.  I imagine their linear density is also significantly larger than the higher notes in order to reduce their length.

While I was dubious about it to begin with, it appears that in fact, there’s no justification for the inflection point that a typical piano has in it’s exterior.  It’s simply an artifact of the arrangement of the lower notes, and probably aesthetics.

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Leave a Reply